Percy Jackson critics never saw any value in the movie adaptations, but Netflix officially proves them wrong. Rick Riordan’s Percy Jackson & the Olympians book series has maintained a massive fanbase since its release, and the fandom has only grown over time. Like most great YA series, Percy Jackson caught the eye of Hollywood executives who purchased the book rights early on.
Five years after the first book debuted, 20th Century Fox released the first of two movie adaptations. Despite Rick Riordan’s offer to help, he had zero creative control, and his opinions about the script were brushed off (via Rick Riordan’s website). Unfortunately, it didn’t receive the positive reaction the filmmakers had hoped for. The Percy Jackson movies were hated by most of the fandom, and film critics didn’t see them as much better.
A Compendium of Enchanted Cinema How Well Do You Know Fantasy Movies? “Magic always comes with a price.”
SpellsWingardium Leviosa
BeastsHere be dragons
KingdomsLong live the king
QuestsThe hero’s journey
MagicWhat lies ahead
01
Across the Harry Potter films, the boy wizard is rarely without his loyal companion — a snowy owl gifted to him by Hagrid on his eleventh birthday. What is the owl’s name?
✓ Correct! Hedwig — the snowy owl Harry receives in The Philosopher’s Stone — becomes one of his most beloved companions. Errol is the Weasleys’ ancient, accident-prone owl; Pigwidgeon is Ron’s tiny hyperactive owl; and Crookshanks is Hermione’s ginger cat — not an owl at all.
✗ Not quite! The answer is Hedwig. Errol is the Weasleys’ clumsy family owl, Pigwidgeon is Ron’s tiny owl from later books, and Crookshanks is Hermione’s cat. Hedwig is the snowy owl Hagrid buys Harry for his birthday — even getting her own leitmotif from composer John Williams.
02
In Rob Reiner’s 1987 cult classic The Princess Bride, the farm boy Westley answers Buttercup’s every demand with the same three words — which she comes to realize actually mean “I love you.” What does he say?
✓ Correct! “As you wish” is Westley’s signature line — and the film’s emotional core. “Inconceivable!” is Vizzini’s catchphrase (prompting Inigo’s famous “You keep using that word…”). The other two were never in William Goldman’s script — the whole point is that three plain words carry all the meaning.
✗ Not quite! The answer is “As you wish.” “Inconceivable!” belongs to the Sicilian Vizzini. Buttercup slowly realizes that Westley’s endlessly repeated “As you wish” is really his way of saying “I love you” — one of the most quoted lines in fantasy cinema.
03
The 2006 Spanish-language masterpiece Pan’s Labyrinth blends a fascist-era fairy tale with the grim reality of post-Civil War Spain, featuring the nightmarish Pale Man. Which director created this dark fantasy?
✓ Correct! Guillermo del Toro wrote and directed Pan’s Labyrinth, designing the Faun and the eyeless Pale Man himself. He’d later win Best Director and Best Picture for The Shape of Water. Cuarón directed Prisoner of Azkaban; Almodóvar is Spain’s great melodramatist; Rodriguez is del Toro’s close friend but made Sin City and Spy Kids.
✗ Not quite! The answer is Guillermo del Toro. Alfonso Cuarón (a fellow “Three Amigos” of Mexican cinema) directed Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, Pedro Almodóvar makes Spanish melodramas, and Robert Rodriguez made Sin City. Del Toro’s creature designs in Pan’s Labyrinth are now iconic.
04
In The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe (2005), the four Pevensie children first stumble into the snowy land of Narnia by passing through what object?
✓ Correct! It’s a wardrobe — it’s right there in the title. Lucy hides inside during a game and finds the snow and lamppost of Narnia beyond the fur coats. A magical painting actually appears in the sequel, The Voyage of the Dawn Treader; the mirror and well are red herrings from other fantasy tales.
✗ Not quite! The answer is a wardrobe — literally named in the title. Lucy Pevensie pushes past the coats and steps out into snowy Narnia by the lamppost. (A magical painting does pull the children into the sea in the later film The Voyage of the Dawn Treader — but not here.)
05
The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King (2003) made Oscar history as the first fantasy film to win Best Picture, sweeping every category it was nominated in. How many Academy Awards did it take home?
✓ Correct! Return of the King won all 11 of its nominations — tying Ben-Hur (1959) and Titanic (1997) for the all-time record, and becoming the first (and so far only) fantasy film to win Best Picture. Remarkably, it earned zero acting nominations yet still swept the board clean.
✗ Not quite! The answer is 11 — a perfect clean sweep. Return of the King tied Ben-Hur and Titanic for the most Oscar wins ever and broke fantasy’s long Best Picture drought. Fellowship of the Ring won 4 and The Two Towers won 2; the finale took everything it was nominated for.
06
In the swashbuckling Pirates of the Caribbean films, Johnny Depp earned an Oscar nomination playing a swaggering, kohl-eyed pirate captain reportedly inspired by Keith Richards. What is the character’s name?
✓ Correct! Captain Jack Sparrow — Depp’s loose-limbed, rum-soaked performance earned a surprise Best Actor nomination for The Curse of the Black Pearl. Will Turner is the blacksmith hero (Orlando Bloom), Davy Jones is the tentacle-faced villain (Bill Nighy), and Hector Barbossa is the mutinous rival captain (Geoffrey Rush).
✗ Not quite! The answer is Captain Jack Sparrow. Will Turner (Orlando Bloom) is the earnest blacksmith, Davy Jones (Bill Nighy) is the squid-faced sea villain, and Hector Barbossa (Geoffrey Rush) is the cursed rival. It was Depp’s Sparrow — modeled partly on Keith Richards — who earned the Oscar nod.
07
Jim Henson’s 1986 musical fantasy Labyrinth features a teenage Jennifer Connelly navigating a maze to rescue her baby brother from the flamboyant, wild-haired Goblin King Jareth. Which rock legend played Jareth?
✓ Correct! David Bowie played Jareth, writing and performing the film’s songs including “Magic Dance” and “As the World Falls Down.” Tim Curry famously played the demon Darkness in another Ridley Scott fantasy, Legend (also 1985-86). Jagger and Sting are rock icons but never donned Jareth’s glittering cape and wild wig.
✗ Not quite! The answer is David Bowie. Tim Curry played the towering devil Darkness in the rival fantasy Legend around the same time. Bowie not only starred as Jareth the Goblin King but composed and sang the soundtrack — “Magic Dance” remains the film’s signature number.
08
In the 1984 classic The NeverEnding Story, the young warrior Atreyu journeys across the dying realm of Fantasia and befriends a furry, dog-faced luckdragon who carries him through the skies. What is the luckdragon’s name?
✓ Correct! Falkor (Falkor the luckdragon) is the friendly, scale-and-fur covered dragon who aids Atreyu and Bastian. Artax is Atreyu’s horse, lost heartbreakingly in the Swamp of Sadness; Gmork is the wolf-like servant of The Nothing; and Bastian is the real-world boy reading the story who is ultimately drawn into it.
✗ Not quite! The answer is Falkor. Artax is Atreyu’s beloved horse (the Swamp of Sadness scene scarred a generation), Gmork is the menacing wolf-beast serving The Nothing, and Bastian is the bullied boy reading the book. Falkor is the soaring luckdragon — one of fantasy cinema’s most cherished creatures.
The Grimoire Closes · Quest Complete Your Fantasy Rank
/ 8
Archmage of the Silver Screen — or still lost in the labyrinth?
They only lived on in the pop-culture zeitgeist in infamy. However, it looks like the tides are turning. Netflix recently took a chance on the Percy Jackson movies, adding them to its large catalog on June 15. Just two days later, the movies have done the impossible.
Percy Jackson & the Olympians: The Lightning Thief is at number three, and Percy Jackson: Sea of Monsters is number four on the Top 10 Movies list. This would have been absolutely unthinkable back when the movies came out. However, their streaming success on Netflix proves folks were a little too harsh on the 2010s movie duology. No matter how unfaithful they are to the source material, they still have entertainment value.
The Percy Jackson Movies Are Entertaining When Separated From The Rick Riordan Books
Logan Lerman as Percy Jackson in The Lightning Thief
As a fervent fan of the Percy Jackson books, I think the 2010s movies were terrible adaptations. They’re hollowed-out versions of the stories. Frankly, the movies only shared a loose premise and the main characters. That said, they are actually great popcorn movies when viewed as completely separate entities from the Percy Jackson franchise. I thought that in the 2010s, to the point that I own the movies on DVD, and I still think it now.
Popcorn movies are judged by their entertainment value and escapism. They don’t need superb storytelling and character development. They are meant to be enjoyable, mindless fun with mainstream appeal. The Percy Jackson movies did a lot wrong, but they also did some things right. The duology is fast-paced, action-packed, and 100% escapism.
They embrace the spirit of adventure and fun, rather than trying to be something they aren’t. They’re high-budget and visually engaging enough to keep the movie going. Logan Lerman gives a good performance as Percy, which makes it easy to watch. Both Percy Jackson movies are pretty thematically empty, which makes it easier for the audience to turn off their brains while watching. Ultimately, they are the kind of media to watch when folks just want to relax without thinking about what they’re watching too much.
Why The Percy Jackson Fandom Has Taken A 180 On The Peter Jackson Movie Duology
The popularity of the Percy Jackson movies might seem surprising, given the initial responses, but it actually makes sense for them to have a comeback 13 years after Percy Jackson: Sea of Monsters. There were always quiet fans of the movies. Back then, the fandom wasn’t friendly towards people who liked them, meaning those opinions weren’t as widely expressed.
Additionally, the movies are experiencing the nostalgia effect. It has been long enough for people to look back on the movies through rose-colored glasses. What’s more, the movies are also bound to elicit less extreme negative emotional reactions now that there’s some distance from their releases. It’s the same way the Star Wars prequels are now loved, even though they were originally disliked.
On top of that, Disney+’s Percy Jackson and the Olympians has entered the picture, meaning there are more versions to compare and a less unified Percy Jackson fandom. I personally think the TV show is better than the movies, but neither is as good as the books. There are a variety of opinions, though, which is fine. Some people who dislike the show now see the Percy Jackson movies as a preferable alternative, boosting its popularity. Overall, the Percy Jackson movies are seemingly finding their second life on Netflix now that attitudes have softened, allowing viewers to appreciate them for what they are.
